Rekey vs Change Locks NYC | Which is Better?

When you need to improve your home security, you have two options: rekey your existing locks or replace them entirely. Here is how to decide which is right for you.

What is Rekeying?

Rekeying changes the internal pins of your lock so that a new key works while the old key no longer functions. The lock hardware stays the same. Pros: more affordable than full replacement, keeps existing hardware, quick process 15-30 minutes per lock, all locks can use the same key. Cons: does not upgrade lock security, will not fix damaged or worn locks.

What is Lock Change?

Lock change involves removing the entire lock and installing a new one. This includes new hardware and new keys. Pros: upgrades to modern more secure locks, fixes damaged or worn mechanisms, can change lock style or finish, new warranty on hardware. Cons: more expensive than rekeying, takes longer to install, may require drilling new holes.

When to Rekey

Moving into a new home, lost keys but locks are in good condition, tenant moves out, want all locks to use the same key, or budget is a concern.

When to Change Locks

Locks are old or damaged, after a break-in, upgrading to smart locks, changing lock style or finish, or moving into an older building.

Cost Comparison

Rekeying: $25-$50 per lock. Lock change: $50-$100 per lock. Smart lock installation: $150-$350. High-security upgrade: $100-$200 per lock.

Professional Advice

For most situations, rekeying is the more cost-effective option. However, if your locks are old, damaged, or you want to upgrade security features, lock replacement is the better choice.

Contact Us

Need help deciding? Call (347) 557-6988 for expert advice.